Most People Think Pressure Is the Enemy. Elite Performers Know Differently.
Elite performers have a secret relationship with pressure.
While most people try to minimize pressure or cope with it, elite performers have learned to transform it into fuel. They don’t just tolerate high-stakes moments – they actively seek them out.
After two decades of coaching under pressure, I’ve discovered exactly how this transformation happens.
It’s not about being naturally gifted or fearless.
It’s about understanding the five distinct levels of pressure response, and knowing how to move up what I call the Pressure Performance Pyramid™.
The Five Levels: From Fear to Fuel
Here’s how most people progress through their relationship with pressure:
Level 1: Avoid Pressure
People at this level dodge big moments entirely. They can compete in low-stakes situations but find reasons to skip the important games. Why? Because they’re protecting their ego from potential failure.
Level 2: Survive Pressure
They show up, but feel hijacked. People at this level are tight, reactive, completely obsessed with outcomes. They have some experience under pressure, but their performance is erratic at best.
Level 3: Manage Pressure
People here develop routines and coping strategies. They view these routines as ways to deal with the threat of pressure. They’re more consistent than Level 2, but still drained by high-stakes situations. This is where most people stop.
Level 4: Use Pressure
This is the activation line…the game changer. At this level, pressure becomes information and energy. People frame challenges as opportunities and deliver peak performance when it matters most.
Level 5: Play with Pressure
People at this level own the pressure completely. They actively seek out the biggest stages because they know that’s where they perform best. Most importantly: their sense of self-worth never changes based on outcomes.
When Pressure Stops Being the Enemy
Most performance advice gets people to Level 3 and stops there. They learn breathing techniques, positive self-talk, and pre-performance routines.
But there’s a massive gap between managing pressure and using it.
Level 3 thinking: “I have these routines to cope with the stress of this big moment.”
Level 4 thinking: “This pressure is information telling me something important is happening. It’s energy I can use to perform at my best.”
Level 4 is what I call the activation line because this is where pressure transforms from performance killer to performance enhancer. Below this line, pressure diminishes performance. Above it, pressure enhances performance.
The Game-Winning Shot
Think about a basketball player taking a game-winning shot.
Level 1: Avoids the moment, doesn’t want the ball
Level 2: Takes the shot but is tight, focused on not missing
Level 3: Has a routine to manage the pressure of the moment
Level 4: Uses the energy of the moment to elevate their focus
Level 5: Actively wants the ball because they know pressure situations bring out their best
The physical skill might be identical across levels 3, 4, and 5. The difference is entirely in their relationship with the pressure of the moment.
How This Plays Out in Business
Business leaders move through these levels throughout their careers. Early on, they might avoid high-stakes presentations or difficult conversations (Level 1).
As they grow, they force themselves into these situations but feel completely reactive (Level 2).
With experience, they develop routines to manage the stress of leadership (Level 3).
But the leaders who truly excel—the ones who seem to get calmer as stakes get higher – have learned to use pressure as fuel (Level 4) or even seek it out because they know it brings out their best (Level 5).
Finding Your Level
People can’t skip levels. Someone who’s avoiding pressure (Level 1) needs to learn to survive it (Level 2) before they can manage it (Level 3).
But the process can be accelerated with specific actions:
To move from Level 1 to 2: Start with lower-stakes practice opportunities before tackling the big ones
To move from Level 2 to 3: Track what works and what doesn’t after each high-pressure situation
To move from Level 3 to 4: Next time you feel pressure, ask “What is this telling me?” instead of “How do I manage this?”
To move from Level 4 to 5: Notice when you’re most excited vs. most nervous – they should start feeling similar
Most people can immediately identify their current level when they think about their biggest professional challenges.
Your Choice To Make
The pressure isn’t going away. Your biggest opportunities will always come with significant stakes.
Elite performers aren’t born with a different relationship to pressure. They’ve simply learned to move up the pyramid – and you can too.
Right now, you’re at one of the five levels. The question is: Will you let pressure diminish your performance, or will you learn to let it fuel your best work?
That choice determines whether you’ll spend your career managing your limitations or exceeding them.
Be Bold. Take Action. Leave a Mark.
Todd Herman
P.S. If someone forwarded you this article, you can subscribe to my weekly ‘A Peak Life’ newsletter below. Every week I’ll share one idea, framework, or perspective that will help you lead a life you’re excited for.