What Success Actually Looks Like (And Why Most People Get It Wrong)
Ask ten business owners to define success and you’ll get ten vague answers.
“Grow the business.”
“Increase revenue.”
“Build a great team.”
“Make an impact.”
These aren’t definitions of success. They’re wishes disguised as goals.
I saw this while coaching an executive who was planning a major initiative.
When I asked him what success would look like, he gave me the standard response:
“We want to grow and scale the business.”
So I asked a different question:
“How will you know when you’ve won?”
In the silence that followed, the real problem became clear: he had a direction, but no finish line.
The Problem With Vague Ideas
Here’s what I’ve observed after working with elite performers for 29+ years: the people who achieve the most extraordinary results are obsessed with one thing.
They’re obsessed with defining what success actually looks like.
Not in vague terms. Not in general directions. In specific, measurable, time-bound outcomes that leave no room for interpretation.
While many people are pointing themselves towards vague goals, elite performers are defining the exact conditions for victory.
The One Question You Need To Ask
There is one question, that, if you define thoroughly, can set you apart from average.
It’s the question you should ask in every meeting, for every project, before every major decision:
“What does success look like?”
Not “What do we want to achieve?” Not “What’s our goal?”
Why Specificity Scares People
One of the main reasons people avoid defining success in specific terms is because they’re afraid of being held accountable to them.
But here’s the thing: vague goals create specific failures.
When you don’t define success clearly, you can’t measure progress accurately.
When you can’t measure progress, you can’t make informed adjustments.
When you can’t make informed adjustments, you move toward failure.
The definition you set for success defines your navigation system.
Without it . . . you drift.
How To Turn A Vague Goal Into A Destination
Goals tell you what you want. Success definitions tell you when you’ve got it.
Vague Goal: “Increase revenue”
Success: “Increase revenue by 25% while maintaining current profit margins and customer satisfaction scores above 90%”
Vague Goal: “Build a great team”
Success: “Hire three senior-level professionals who can operate independently within 90 days and reduce my weekly management time by 15 hours”
Vague Goal: “Improve our processes”
Success: “Implement systems that reduce project completion time by 30% and eliminate the need for weekend work”
See the difference? Goals are directions. Success defines the destination.
The Three-Level Success Framework
Here’s the framework I use with my clients to create a full picture of what success looks like:
Level 1: Minimum Viable Success
What’s the least you need to achieve for this to be worth the effort?
Level 2: Target Success
What would you be genuinely excited to achieve?
Level 3: Extraordinary Success
What would exceed your wildest expectations?
This framework does three things:
- It sets a floor (so you know when to cut your losses).
- It sets a target (so you know where to aim).
- It sets a ceiling (so you know when you’ve won big).
Adding the Inversion Principle
There’s a principle I bring up often when I coach; it’s what Charlie Munger called inversion thinking.
Instead of just defining success, you define failure.
Ask this question:
“If we looked back on this year as a complete disaster, what would have happened?”
Then you build your plan around preventing the complete disaster.
If failure means losing your best team members, you build retention strategies. If failure means running out of cash, you create more conservative projections. If failure means missing key deadlines, you build in buffer time.
By defining both success and failure clearly, you create boundaries for your decision-making.
How To Focus Your Effort
Every definition of success needs a time component. Not just “when” but “by when.”
“Increase revenue by 25%” is better than “increase revenue.”
But “increase revenue by 25% by December 31st” is better than both.
Time constraints create urgency. Urgency creates focus. Focus creates results.
Success Needs Context
This is the question to ask:
“Success compared to what?”
Are you trying to:
- Improve on your past performance?
- Match a competitor’s results?
- Achieve an industry benchmark?
- Reach a personal milestone?
The comparison point matters because it changes your strategy.
The Resource Reality Check
Once you’ve defined success, stress-test it by asking:
“Do I have the resources to achieve this?”
Remember the four-resource filter: People, Money, Time, Tools.
If your success definition requires resources you don’t have, you have three options:
- Acquire the resources
- Adjust the timeline
- Redefine success
Most people skip this step and wonder why they fall short.
You Know the Destination, Bring Everyone With You
If your definition of success only lives in your head, it’s worthless.
Leading at an elite level requires you to communicate your definition clearly and repeatedly to everyone involved.
You make sure every team member understands not just what they’re working toward, but how they’ll know when they’ve achieved it.
This alignment is what separates high-performing teams from groups of individuals working in the same direction.
Create Your Guardrails
Once you’ve defined success, you need a system to track progress toward it.
This is where a need for course correction becomes apparent.
If you’re trying to increase revenue by 25% in 12 months, you should know where you stand every month.
If you’re behind, you can adjust. If you’re ahead, you can accelerate or raise the bar.
Celebrate the Wins
Recognizing and celebrating wins reinforces the behaviors that lead to success.
It creates positive associations with achievement.
It motivates you to set and get to the next level.
This is one of the most important steps. Don’t skip it.
The More You Do, the More You Get
When you consistently define success clearly, you set yourself up to start achieving it more often.
Not because the work becomes easier, but because your focus becomes sharper.
You stop wasting energy on activities that don’t move you toward your defined success.
You make better decisions because you have clear criteria for evaluation.
Most importantly, you build confidence in your ability to achieve what you set out to achieve.
One of the most important aspects of peak performance is trusting your own capability.
Your Success Audit
Look at your current objectives – business, personal, whatever matters to you.
For each one, ask:
- How will I know when I’ve succeeded?
- What would failure look like?
- What resources do I need to succeed?
- How will I track progress?
- How will I celebrate success?
If you can’t answer these questions clearly, you don’t have a plan. You have wishes.
Your Next Move
It’s okay to be unapologetically specific about what you want.
It’s okay to set measurable targets. It’s okay to create deadlines. It’s okay to define exactly what winning looks like for you.
Specificity isn’t limiting. It’s liberating. When you know exactly where you’re going, you can focus all your energy on getting there.
The most successful people aren’t necessarily the ones with the biggest dreams. They’re the ones with a clear definition of success and the discipline to pursue it.
Todd Herman
P.S. If someone forwarded you this article, you can subscribe to my weekly ‘A Peak Life’ newsletter below. Every week I’ll share one idea, framework, or perspective that will help you lead a life you’re excited for.