The Decision-Making Framework That Prevents 80% of Business Failures
I’ve noticed a pattern in failed projects over the years.
They often share similar blind spots.
This became clear while I was coaching a business team that was bringing on a new team member.
On the surface, it seemed straightforward: hire someone good, train them up, watch them succeed.
But when I asked the team leader about the biggest risk factors, his first instinct was to focus on the new hire.
“What if she doesn’t understand our culture? What if she can’t handle the pace?”
He was looking at the wrong variable.
The real risk wasn’t the new person. It was in the existing team member stepping into a new leadership role as a result of the new hire.
This is the person who would be responsible for training new people.
This person was great in their current role, but they also had a track record of saying “it’s easier if I just do it myself” instead of delegating.
This is a common blind spot. We focus on the obvious variables while ignoring the systemic ones.
The Four-Resource Reality
After almost three decades of coaching teams – from professional sports to Fortune 50 boardrooms – I’ve identified a pattern: every initiative, goal, or project operates within four main resources.
People. Money. Time. Tools.
That’s it. Every success or failure can be traced back to assumptions you made about one of these four areas.
Most leaders focus on strategy and execution.
Leading at an elite level requires analyzing these four resources first, strategy second.
Resource #1: People (The Hidden Variable)
People are the most complex and unpredictable resource. Which makes them the biggest risk factor in almost every initiative.
When you bring in someone new, the risk lies with the existing people whose roles are about to change.
With the team I was coaching, for example, everyone was focused on whether the new associate would succeed.
But the real question was:
“Will [existing team member] be great at training this person?”
In this case, this person’s natural reflex was to handle things themself rather than delegate.
That initiative is what made them excellent at their current role. But that same strength would become a weakness in their new role as a trainer and leader.
The People Resource Questions:
There are four questions that can help you identify and address people risks:
- Who are the key people this initiative depends on?
- What assumptions am I making about their capabilities?
- Whose role is changing, and how might that affect their performance?
- Do the people involved have experience in similar situations?
Once you’ve answered these, adjust accordingly.
Resource #2: Money (The Obvious One)
Money is usually the most obvious resource constraint, but it’s often not the most important one.
The key isn’t just:
“Do we have enough money?”
It’s:
“Are we allocating money to the right things at the right time?”
I’ve seen businesses fail not because they lacked funding, but because they spent money on the wrong priorities.
They were too focused on optimizing for efficiency, and not enough on effectiveness or performance.
The Money Resource Questions:
Use these four questions to analyze this resource:
- Is this the right time to make this investment?
- What’s the opportunity cost of spending money here versus elsewhere?
- Are we solving a revenue problem or a profit problem?
- What’s our runway if this takes longer than expected?
Remember, it should be allocated to support effectiveness and performance, not just efficiency.
Resource #3: Time (The Finite One)
Time is the only resource you can’t get more of. Yet most leaders treat it as if it’s infinite.
The biggest time trap?
Taking on too many big initiatives simultaneously.
Big projects sound impressive, but they’re resource-intensive and have lower success rates than smaller, focused efforts.
The Time Resource Questions:
Answer these questions to get clear on whether your spending time on things that will have the greatest impact in your business:
- How many major initiatives are we running simultaneously?
- What’s the realistic timeline, not the optimistic one?
- What other priorities will this impact?
- Are we mixing big bets with sure wins?
The most effective leaders I know are very good at saying no. Simplifying is one of the greatest time-saving skills you can learn.
Resource #4: Tools and Skills (The Multiplier)
This is the most underutilized resource in almost every organization I work with.
You probably have access to tools, systems, and capabilities that you’re not fully leveraging.
I worked with a team that was struggling with efficiency. Instead of hiring more people, we did an audit of their existing tools. They were using less than 30% of the capabilities in their current software stack.
The Tools Resource Questions:
Use these questions to audit your tools:
- What tools do we already have that we’re underutilizing?
- What skills exist in our organization that we’re not leveraging?
- Is this a capability we need to build or buy?
- What would make the biggest impact if we implemented it in the next six weeks?
It’s much easier to build on something that already exists than to start from zero.
The Four Steps Most Leaders Skip
Here’s how to apply the four-resource filter to any decision:
Step 1: Define Success
Before you analyze anything, get crystal clear on what success actually looks like. Not vague goals like “grow the business,” but specific outcomes like “increase revenue by 25% while maintaining current profit margins.”
Step 2: Map the Resources
For each resource category, identify:
- What you have available
- What you’re assuming
- Where the risks lie
- What could go wrong
Step 3: Stress-Test Your Assumptions
Ask yourself: “If I’m wrong about this assumption, what happens to the project?” Focus extra attention on your riskiest assumptions.
Step 4: Plan for Resource Constraints
What happens if you have less time than expected? Less money? What if a key person becomes unavailable?
The Inversion Principle
Elite leaders use inversion thinking – a concept Charlie Munger has talked about for decades. Instead of just planning for success, they ask:
“What would complete failure look like?”
If failure means losing your best team members, you build retention strategies. If failure means running out of cash, you create more conservative financial projections. If failure means missing deadlines, you build in buffer time.
How To Make Success Predictable
Here’s what happens when you consistently apply this filter: better decisions, made faster.
You stop getting surprised by “unexpected” problems because you’ve already thought through the resource constraints. You stop overcommitting because you understand the true cost of initiatives. You stop failing for preventable reasons.
Most importantly, you start succeeding more predictably.
Your Next Decision
The next time you’re facing a major decision, don’t start with strategy. Start with resources.
Map out the people, money, time, and tools involved. Identify your assumptions. Stress-test the risky ones.
Then, and only then, move to strategy and execution.
In a world where many leaders are optimistically unprepared, being realistic is a competitive advantage.
Todd Herman
P.S. If someone forwarded you this article, you can subscribe to my weekly ‘A Peak Life’ newsletter below. Every week I’ll share one idea, framework, or perspective that will help you lead a life you’re excited for.